Artificial intelligence is rapidly becoming an indispensable tool across financial operations, with nearly universal adoption for informing estimates and judgments reviewed by auditors. However, this swift technological integration is significantly outpacing the development of robust governance, documentation, and resource allocation strategies within compliance and finance departments. Recent surveys highlight critical gaps, revealing that while AI is deeply embedded, the ability to audit its outputs and manage evolving compliance demands remains a significant challenge. Furthermore, dedicated compliance and sustainability specialists are heavily reliant on manual processes, and tax departments are consistently operating with insufficient resources, impacting their perceived value and operational effectiveness.
AI Integration Near-Universal, Governance Lags Significantly
A comprehensive survey conducted by BDO, polling 200 financial leaders at U.S. organizations, reveals an astonishing near-unanimity in the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI). The study indicates that a staggering 99% of these organizations are leveraging AI to generate or inform at least one financial estimate or judgment that undergoes review by their external auditors. This widespread integration underscores AI’s transformative impact on how financial data is processed and analyzed.
Delving deeper into specific applications, the BDO survey found that a significant majority (62%) of companies are utilizing AI for the calculation of cash flow or earnings forecasts. An additional 55% reported employing AI for critical tasks such as tax provisions, deferred tax calculations, and fair value measurements or asset valuations. These figures point to AI’s fundamental role in core financial decision-making and reporting processes, moving beyond experimental applications to become an integral part of day-to-day operations.
Despite this near-ubiquitous deployment, a stark contrast emerges when examining the confidence in auditing AI-generated outputs. The survey reveals that less than half of the respondents (49%) possess the necessary documentation and processes to fully explain and substantiate all AI-assisted outputs. A further 46% can explain most outputs but acknowledge significant gaps in their documentation. This disparity strongly suggests that the pace of AI implementation is outpacing the establishment of effective governance frameworks, comprehensive documentation practices, and the evidentiary requirements necessary for robust oversight. This gap raises concerns about the transparency, accuracy, and auditability of AI-driven financial insights.
The BDO survey also shed light on financial leaders’ views regarding continuous auditing. A substantial portion of respondents see value in a more year-round auditing approach, citing potential benefits such as earlier risk identification, a reduction in year-end surprises, and more timely insights into financial reporting issues. However, readiness for such a transition appears to be critically low, with only 6% of organizations reporting they are prepared for continuous auditing.
The primary impediments to adopting continuous auditing are multifaceted. A significant 71% of respondents identified the need for better internal data infrastructure as a major obstacle. This is closely followed by the requirement for stronger AI governance (63%), clearer regulatory guidance (62%), and enhanced auditor capability in continuous auditing methods (57%). Cost considerations also play a role, with 48% citing financial investment as a barrier. These findings collectively indicate that while the aspiration for more agile and proactive auditing exists, the foundational elements – particularly data infrastructure and AI governance – are not yet sufficiently mature to support this evolution.
Compliance and Sustainability Specialists Burdened by Manual Processes and Outdated Tools
In parallel to the challenges in financial auditing, a global survey by Assent and Germany’s Pforzheim University, involving 131 specialists and managers across industries such as automotive and electronics, reveals a persistent reliance on outdated tools for managing product compliance and sustainability. The study found that an overwhelming 70% of these professionals continue to rely on spreadsheets for managing these critical functions.
This reliance on manual data management comes at a significant cost to productivity. The survey indicates that 69% of respondents dedicate up to two hours daily to manual, repetitive tasks associated with managing compliance and sustainability data. This time expenditure detracts from strategic initiatives and proactive risk management, highlighting a significant inefficiency within these departments.
Data challenges further exacerbate these issues. Almost three in five respondents (57%) identified incomplete data and data integrity as their most significant hurdles in meeting compliance and sustainability reporting requirements. Additionally, 55% reported that poor data quality and timeliness prevent their supply chain carbon data from meeting their own internal standards. This points to a systemic problem with data collection, validation, and accessibility, which is fundamental to accurate reporting and informed decision-making in these complex domains. The implications of unreliable data can range from regulatory penalties to reputational damage and missed opportunities for environmental stewardship.
Tax Departments Consistently Under-Resourced, Impacting Value Perception
The challenges extend to tax departments, which have consistently faced resource constraints for at least three consecutive years. A survey by the Thomson Reuters Institute and the Tax Executives Institute, encompassing 244 senior decision-makers in corporate tax departments, found that a majority (53%) believe their teams are under-resourced, lacking the necessary personnel and financial backing to optimize their functions.
The primary driver for this persistent under-resourcing appears to be a mismatch between workload growth and recruitment capacity. Among under-resourced departments, 33% cited that their workload has escalated faster than their ability to hire new staff. Furthermore, a notable 19% admitted to not requesting larger budgets due to a lack of confidence in their approval, suggesting a perception of limited influence or understanding of their needs by senior leadership.
This scarcity of resources may be negatively impacting how tax departments are perceived within their organizations. The survey revealed that nearly three-fourths (73%) of tax leaders believe their departments are viewed primarily as cost centers, or at best, as having an even split between cost center and value creator. This perception is in contrast to their own internal belief that they are actively building a value narrative for senior leadership.
The disconnect in perception is further illuminated by the metrics regularly reported to Chief Financial Officers (CFOs). CFOs surveyed indicated that the metrics most frequently reported to them include audit and dispute outcomes (50%), tax authority audits opened (44%), and tax penalties incurred (41%). These metrics are predominantly focused on downside avoidance, emphasizing risk mitigation rather than value creation. This suggests that while tax teams may be focusing on strategic contributions, CFOs are primarily receiving data that frames their departments as cost-management entities. The survey concluded that this divergence in scorecards is a key factor in the differing perceptions of whether the tax department operates as a cost center or a value creator.
Broader Implications and Future Outlook
The findings from these three distinct yet interconnected surveys paint a consistent picture of an evolving business landscape grappling with the rapid integration of new technologies and increasing regulatory complexity, while struggling with foundational resource and process management.
The near-universal adoption of AI in financial forecasting and auditing, as highlighted by BDO, signifies a profound shift in operational capabilities. However, the identified lag in governance and auditability presents a significant risk. Organizations that fail to establish clear protocols for AI oversight, data validation, and the documentation of AI-driven decisions may find themselves vulnerable to errors, biases, and regulatory scrutiny. The push for continuous auditing, while desirable for its proactive benefits, is contingent on significant investments in data infrastructure and AI governance, suggesting a multi-year roadmap for many organizations. The ability of external auditors to effectively review AI-generated outputs will also be a critical determinant of confidence and compliance in the coming years.
The reliance on spreadsheets for product compliance and sustainability management, as evidenced by the Assent and Pforzheim University study, points to a critical bottleneck in modern compliance efforts. In an era of increasingly complex supply chains and stringent environmental, social, and governance (ESG) regulations, manual processes are not only inefficient but also prone to errors that can have severe consequences. The time spent on repetitive tasks could be redirected towards strategic analysis, supplier engagement, and proactive risk mitigation. The challenge of incomplete and poor-quality data underscores the need for robust data management systems and a strategic approach to data governance that extends across the entire supply chain.
The persistent under-resourcing of tax departments, as reported by Thomson Reuters and the Tax Executives Institute, suggests a potential underestimation of the strategic value these departments can provide. In a global economy characterized by complex tax laws and increasing scrutiny from tax authorities, well-resourced tax teams can be instrumental in optimizing tax strategies, managing risks, and contributing to the financial health of an organization. The perception gap between tax leaders and CFOs regarding value creation highlights a communication challenge and potentially a missed opportunity for tax departments to demonstrate their strategic impact beyond cost management.
Collectively, these reports underscore the urgent need for organizations to align their technological adoption, resource allocation, and governance frameworks. As AI continues its trajectory of integration, businesses must prioritize the development of robust governance and audit capabilities. Similarly, a strategic shift away from manual processes towards more sophisticated data management solutions is crucial for compliance and sustainability functions. For tax departments, demonstrating their value proposition through clear metrics and strategic contributions will be key to securing the resources needed to navigate an increasingly complex tax landscape. The coming years will likely see a significant focus on closing these gaps to ensure that technological advancements and regulatory demands are met with commensurate operational maturity and strategic foresight.
